Skip over navigation

Instructions: To enter the debate, choose your side below, and post your argument. You may vote for the top argument below by clicking the Vote Up button. You cannot vote for your own argument.
Edit: You have 10 minutes to make any changes. Click to edit
Did M. Vick just play the greatest QB game in NFL history?



Choose a Side:
1 YES. Can not do better than that
2 Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
Arguments Posted (18)
  • Sort by:
Page:
 
Posted by berry2 | 6 years ago

1 game does not make the hall of fame

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by psuis1 | 6 years ago

check the stats and QB rating

My Side: YES. Can not do better than that
 
Posted by tomseahawk | 6 years ago

Maybe the game of THIS year, but of History??? Give us a break.

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by TheSportsDude | 6 years ago

No.

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by godux | 6 years ago

Don't forget George Blanda, who also place kicked. Vick is in a different era, hard to compare him but thest game ever ... Any group of football fans over 25 years old can come up with rivals. This is an argument you have to win by a bunch or give up the claim for Vick.

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by Go Kings Go!!! | 6 years ago

All records are made to be broken.

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by zekenyc | 6 years ago

IT HAS NEVER BEEN DONE ONE FOR THE HISTORY BOOKS LOOKING FORWARD TO SEE WHO TOPS THAT.

My Side: YES. Can not do better than that
 
Posted by tollx26 | 6 years ago

He played a tremendous game on a team that literally laid down!! Did Haynesworth get up yet??

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by iskandor | 6 years ago

Needs 3 more quaeters like the first .

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
 
Posted by clasmorr | 6 years ago

Greatest 1at quarter, not greatest game.

My Side: Come on - Johnny U., John Brodie, the Dutchman, even Brady had games just as good or better.
Page:
  • Votes: 3
  • Arguments: 18
  • Tags: NFL
  • Short URL:
Post a Comment (View Guidelines)
Comments (0)

Find Debates
Start Debate
More Debates
 
Debates
Your City: WOODBRIDGE, NJ (change)